Phil Mafah vs Michael Carter dynasty value comparison

Compare Sleeper Agent’s standardized 1QB and Superflex dynasty values, ranks, tiers, age, team context, and production evidence for two nearby RB assets.

Compare inside your Sleeper league Methodology

SIDE BY SIDE

Public dynasty value snapshot

Position: RB
1QB gap: Sleeper Agent currently values Phil Mafah 3.4 points higher in the 1QB public baseline.
Superflex gap: Sleeper Agent currently values Phil Mafah 3.4 points higher in the SF public baseline.
Verdict: Model verdict: Phil Mafah leads this comparison.
Updated: Oct 11, 2026

Phil Mafah

NYG · RB · Age 23

1QB60.2#93 overall · RB33

Superflex60.4#101 overall · RB33

Tier: Cornerstone (1QB) · Cornerstone (SF)

85 carries · 306 rush yards · 34 receptions per 17-game pace

Michael Carter

TEN · RB · Age 27

1QB56.8#119 overall · RB40

Superflex57.0#133 overall · RB40

Tier: Cornerstone (1QB) · Cornerstone (SF)

146 carries · 538 rush yards · 50 receptions per 17-game pace

Updated Oct 11, 2026. Public values use Sleeper Agent’s local model and a fixed 12-team PPR baseline.

VALUE GAPS

Where the model currently separates them

Model verdict: Phil Mafah leads this comparison.
Sleeper Agent currently values Phil Mafah 3.4 points higher in the 1QB public baseline.
Sleeper Agent currently values Phil Mafah 3.4 points higher in the SF public baseline.
The age gap is 4.0 years; age is evaluated on the shared RB curve rather than used as a stand-alone verdict.
Both players sit in the Cornerstone tier in 1QB.
Phil Mafah ranks #93 overall in 1QB vs #119 for Michael Carter.
Both players sit in the Cornerstone tier in Superflex.
Phil Mafah ranks #101 overall in Superflex vs #133 for Michael Carter.
Michael Carter is 4.0 years older than Phil Mafah (age 23 vs age 27). Age is evaluated on the shared RB dynasty curve rather than used as a stand-alone verdict.
Phil Mafah has paced 185.3 PPR points per 17 games vs 153.9 for Michael Carter in the blended production sample.
Michael Carter draws more receiving volume (60 targets vs 34 per 17-game pace).
Michael Carter handles more rushing work (146 carries vs 85 per 17-game pace).
Phil Mafah: 85 carries · 306 rush yards · 34 receptions per 17-game pace.
Michael Carter: 146 carries · 538 rush yards · 50 receptions per 17-game pace.
League-specific roster construction can change the practical trade decision even when one public baseline is higher.

YOUR LEAGUE CHANGES THE ANSWER

Compare the players where the trade would actually happen.

Connect Sleeper to apply lineup demand, scoring, roster depth, ownership, Superflex, TE premium, and team needs.

Connect Sleeper free